A home that adjusts its temperature before we arrive, lowers its blinds during the hottest hours and lets us control the lights remotely offers readily understandable conveniences. When buying, selling or renovating a property, however, the question becomes more specific: how useful are these functions, and how easy will they be to keep working?

From a property perspective, we suggest viewing home automation as one aspect of a home’s quality. Its contribution should be assessed alongside the building, its occupants’ needs and the costs it will entail over time.

Comfort starts with a coherent design

The starting point should be people’s everyday lives. Which tasks recur each day? Which rooms need different settings? What would occupants like to manage while away?

Careful design can coordinate lighting, temperature and shading, so that each function does not require a separate application or a different procedure. SwissEnergy recommends defining objectives at the outset, since automation systems have different capabilities.[1]

For a high-quality home, we therefore suggest assessing how discreetly the technology is integrated: understandable controls, a good fit with the interiors and ease of use for family members and guests.

Quality becomes apparent when managing the home becomes simpler.

Energy savings: potential that needs checking

Adjusting heating to occupancy and coordinating shading with solar exposure can help use energy more efficiently. Automation itself, however, also requires powered devices and standby consumption: the overall balance needs to be considered.[1]

Results also depend on the climate, the equipment and occupants’ habits. ENERGY STAR’s US programme for smart thermostats highlights these differences: average performance measured in one market is not a forecast for an individual building in Ticino.[2]

Owners should therefore ask the designer which consumption they aim to reduce, what baseline they will use and how results will be measured.

Homes occupied intermittently

For a residence used only at certain times, remote heating control can serve a practical purpose: it allows settings to be adjusted during absences and rooms to be prepared before arrival.

SwissEnergy notes that savings potential also depends on the number of occupied days and heating habits. Realising that potential requires correct installation and configuration, with settings suited to the building and its existing heating system.[3]

This use deserves attention when assessing a home intended for occasional stays: the convenience of remote control should be accompanied by access to local assistance.

Compatibility: planning for future updates

A domestic system will have to coexist with devices, applications and services that may change. Before buying, it is worth understanding which components can be replaced individually and which depend on a particular manufacturer.

Standards such as Matter aim to facilitate communication between compatible products and platforms. This does not mean every existing device automatically becomes compatible: updates depend on the product’s capabilities and the manufacturer’s decisions, while some connections require intermediary devices.[4]

The question for the supplier is specific: if I needed to replace a component in a few years, what alternatives would I have?

A home should remain easy to use

A demonstration of automated functions can be persuasive during a property viewing. To assess their everyday usefulness, we suggest an additional check: establish how essential functions can be operated without reaching for a smartphone every time.

It is worth asking which controls remain available during an internet outage. Local operation and remote control are distinct: Matter, for example, uses local connectivity, whereas access from outside the home requires an appropriate connection and configuration.[4]

These characteristics should be checked on the actual installation, ideally through a demonstration by the installer.

Selling a home includes handing over its digital management

For a property equipped with home automation, we suggest preparing a handover file containing:

  • a list of installed devices and functions;
  • instructions and technical documentation;
  • installer and support contacts;
  • subscription costs and required services;
  • a procedure for transferring access and removing previous users’ access.

Digital maintenance also needs attention. SwissEnergy highlights the importance of protecting access and regularly updating the software of connected systems.[1]

An orderly handover helps buyers understand what they are receiving and what responsibilities they will take on.

What does it contribute to property value?

In our assessment, the cost of installing home automation and its contribution to market value should be considered separately. A judgement about an individual property requires consideration of the functions’ usefulness, their condition, future costs and prospective buyers’ expectations.

A straightforward, documented system with available support can be a positive feature when presenting a home. Assigning it an economic contribution, however, requires relevant market evidence: a generic percentage would not provide a sufficient basis.

The key question is how much the technology improves the home and how easy it will be to keep using it.

Studio Antonini & Partners assists owners and buyers in Lugano and Ticino in assessing a property’s characteristics and their implications for management and marketability. To verify home automation systems, this assessment should be complemented by examination by the relevant technical specialists.